The Incomer

Louis Paxton’s The Incomer serves as a quirky exploration of tradition versus modernity, showcasing an Orkney isle where disruption meets the absurd perseverance of its inhabitants. With sharp humor and poignant moments, the film captures the sibling bond between Isla and Sandy as they navigate the threat posed by an awkward council worker seeking to alter their way of life.

The performances here are a delightful blend of charm and awkwardness, particularly that of Domhnall Gleeson, who channels his comedic prowess into a character that’s both endearing and infuriating. Gleeson’s ability to portray vulnerability adds depth to a character that could have easily felt one-dimensional. Meanwhile, Gayle Rankin and Grant O’Rourke create a palpable sibling chemistry that grounds the film’s more surreal comedic elements, reminding viewers of the strength found in familial ties even amidst chaos.

Paxton’s directorial choices reflect a genuine affection for the setting, as the camera frequently drifts across the rugged landscapes of Orkney, capturing the stark beauty of its cliffs and glimmering waters. The rustic sound design, with the distant calls of seabirds and the wind’s howl, envelops the audience in the characters’ environment, merging vibrantly with the narrative. However, the pacing falters occasionally, especially in moments that linger too long on the eccentricities of the island life, which can disrupt the film’s overall momentum.

In many ways, The Incomer echoes the comedic absurdity found in The Late Late Show with James Corden, especially in its awkward engagement with societal issues and its embrace of offbeat narratives. Where Corden’s show leans into celebrity culture with vibrant energy and rapid-fire humor, The Incomer takes a more introspective approach, exploring deep-rooted themes of belonging and identity through its quirky lens.

What works

• Domhnall Gleeson’s charming performance adds complexity.
• Striking cinematography immerses viewers in Orkney’s landscape.
• Quirky humor that captures the absurdity of life.
• Strong themes of family and community connection.

Where it stumbles

• Pacing issues disrupt the narrative flow.
• Some characters feel underdeveloped amidst the ensemble.
• Occasional reliance on quirky tropes that may alienate some viewers.

The Verdict

The Incomer presents an engaging blend of comedy and heartfelt moments, wrapped in the complexities of life on a remote isle. Though it faces pacing challenges, the film successfully encourages reflections on identity and change, driven by crafted performances and a lush setting.

Rating: 3/5