A desolate airplane hangar set against a vast Colorado landscape, evoking isolation and longing.

The Dog Stars

By Couch Critique

3/5
Ridley Scott's post-apocalyptic drama falters despite strong performances and striking visuals, struggling with pace and narrative cohesion.
Directed by Ridley Scott Released
Starring Jacob Elordi, Josh Brolin, Margaret Qualley, Guy Pearce, Benedict Wong
Movie English DramaThrillerAdventure

In The Dog Stars, Ridley Scott ventures into a post-apocalyptic America, crafting a film marked by a delicate balance of dread and hope, yet it ultimately falls short of fully resonating with its ambitious premise.

The film centers on Hig (Jacob Elordi), who lives a secluded life in a dilapidated airplane hangar alongside his loyal dog and a taciturn gunman (Josh Brolin). This stark existence is upended when an enigmatic transmission reverberates through the static of his radio, igniting a quest for its origin. Scott’s direction captures the vast, lonely landscapes of Colorado with a lens that frequently lingers, allowing the weight of isolation to wash over the audience. The cinematography drifts from expansive sky vistas to intimate, cluttered interiors, emphasizing both Hig’s alienation and longing for connection.

Elordi’s performance anchors the film, delivering a compelling mix of vulnerability and resolve. He navigates Hig’s internal struggles with a quiet intensity, even if at times he grapples with the broader emotional arcs that Scott tries to encapsulate. Brolin complements this with a rugged, stone-faced portrayal, injecting a sense of urgency and peril into Hig’s mundane existence. The chemistry between the two creates moments of genuine tension, though at times the script falters, leaning too heavily on cliché dialogue that detracts from their complex bond.

Scott’s return to the genre of speculative fiction invites immediate comparisons to his previous work, Blade Runner 2049. While that film intricately explores themes of identity and humanity set against a sprawling urban dystopia, The Dog Stars opts for a more intimate narrative, wrestling with personal loss and connection in an isolationist setting. Both films showcase Scott’s visual prowess, yet Blade Runner 2049 achieves a lyrical resonance that The Dog Stars struggles to capture amid its existential meandering.

The pacing occasionally stumbles, reflecting a rhythm that is both reflective and disjointed, as it oscillates between moments of introspection and tension. Some scenes linger too long, leaving the viewer feeling trapped in Hig’s solitude rather than intrigued by it. Additionally, the conclusion, while hopeful, seems abrupt and less satisfying, denying the film its opportunity for a more meaningful catharsis.

What works:

  • Striking cinematography immerses viewers in a hauntingly desolate world.
  • Jacob Elordi’s performance presents layered emotional depth.
  • The friendship between Hig and the gunman offers unexpected moments of tension and warmth.

Where it stumbles:

  • Script occasionally relies on clichĂ© dialogue that undermines character depth.
  • Pacing issues create disjointed emotional beats.
  • Conclusion feels abrupt and leaves questions unanswered.

The Verdict

The Dog Stars showcases moments of brilliance in its visual storytelling and character dynamics but ultimately struggles to weave a cohesive narrative, leaving it an intriguing yet flawed entry in Scott’s filmography.

Discussion

No replies yet. Be the first to share your take — hit Reply at the top of the review.